Zach Cregger may have made the best Resident Evil movie yet, but a faction of fans aren't happy about it

Director Zach Cregger’s upcoming Resident Evil film, scheduled for release on September 18, 2026, has sparked debate among fans over its visual choices and departure from established game protagonists. Responding to skepticism regarding the project's visual fidelity and narrative scope, Cregger has defended his approach, clarifying that his goal is to capture the franchise's survival horror roots through an original story set within the game universe.

Fan Skepticism Over Aesthetics and Adaptations

Criticism from a faction of the Resident Evil fanbase centers on visual differences and departures from game lore. Fans have cited discrepancies such as modern technology like iPhones in the setting or the absence of specific environmental elements like the snow-covered streets featured in Resident Evil 2.

Additional frustration stems from the decision not to directly adapt the plots or characters of the games. Some fans have also raised concerns over potential comedic undertones, pointing to Cregger’s background in sketch comedy as part of The Whitest Kids U'Know.

Steering Clear of Iconic Characters

Rather than recasting famous game leads, Cregger's film takes place alongside the events of Resident Evil 2 using original characters. Cregger stated that established heroes belong in the games themselves rather than live-action re-interpretations.

"I'm not going to be able to improve on Leon... I feel like Leon exists in the games and anyone I cast and any haircut I give him or any line of dialogue I make him say, it's just not going to be Leon because Leon exists," Cregger said.

Cregger emphasized that his primary objective is recreating the feel of playing the original series. "What I'd rather do is tell an original story that lives in the world of the games, that obeys the rules of the games largely, but feels more like the experience you get when you're playing the games," Cregger explained. "That is leaning into the survival horror aspect of it—it's not survival action, it's survival horror."

Honoring Game Rules and Mechanics

Addressing dedicated players directly, Cregger affirmed his admiration for Capcom's series while distancing his project from past film adaptations. "I want fans of the games to just know that I am a giant fan of the games. I am making this movie to celebrate the games. I haven't seen the other movies," Cregger said.

To bridge the original story with fan expectations, the movie includes nods to signature series elements, including the franchise's iconic save-point typewriters, though these references are withheld until later in the trailer to build mystery.

---

• PC Gamer Hero image: https://cdn.mos.cms.futurecdn.net/TpdoYYfvJvaaCCJLdHMfqf-1280-80.png